top of page

Do You Need Landlord Insurance in Ontario If You Rent Out Part of Your Home

Nov 3
10 min read

Yes, in almost every case. The day someone outside your household starts paying you to live in a property you own, a standard home insurance policy may no longer be the right policy for the risk you actually have, and a claim connected to that rental may not be paid.


This catches a lot of people, and more of them every year. Ontario now allows up to three residential units on most residential lots without a rezoning, which has turned basement apartments, in-law suites and garden homes into an ordinary way for families to manage a mortgage. Plenty of those owners have never thought of themselves as landlords. Their insurer will.


This guide to landlord insurance in Ontario is written for you if any of these describe your situation:


  • You rent out a basement apartment, in-law suite or garden suite

  • You moved and kept your previous house or condo as a rental

  • A relative pays you rent to live in a unit you own

  • You rent a cottage or a room out by the week or the month

  • You started renting at some point and never told your insurer


It covers what changes when you rent, what a landlord policy adds, what it still will not pay for, and the handful of things to settle before a tenant moves in.


Two storey Ontario house with a side entrance to a basement apartment, the kind of rental that needs landlord insurance in Ontario
A separate entrance down to a basement suite is now a common sight across York Region, and it changes how the whole house is insured.

Does home insurance cover a rental unit in Ontario?

Usually not in the way owners assume. A homeowner policy is priced and worded for a home lived in by you and your family, and renting out all or part of it changes how the property is used in a way insurers treat as material to the risk.


That word, material, comes from the statutory conditions in Ontario's Insurance Act (external, open in new tab), which are written into property policies. One of them deals with a material change in risk. In plain terms, if something within your control and knowledge changes the risk in a meaningful way, and you do not tell the insurer, coverage for the part affected can be lost. Renting out a unit is the textbook example.


Here is how that plays out. A space heater in the basement suite starts a fire. The adjuster arrives, finds a tenant, a lease and a separate entrance, and learns none of it was ever disclosed. The building claim can be reduced or refused, and if the tenant was hurt, the liability claim against you may be refused as well. Non-disclosure can also lead to the policy being cancelled outright, which makes the next policy harder to find.


None of this is difficult to avoid. It starts with telling your broker before the tenant moves in, not after something goes wrong.


What does landlord insurance cover in Ontario?

Landlord insurance covers the building you rent out, the appliances and furnishings you supply, the rent you lose while the unit is unlivable after an insured loss, and your liability as the owner of a rented property.


The clearest way to see it is side by side with the home policy most people already have.


What is protected

Homeowner policy (you live there)

Landlord or rental dwelling policy

The building

Yes, while it is owner occupied

Yes, written for a dwelling that is rented

Appliances and furnishings you supply

Covered as your household contents

Covered as landlord contents, such as the fridge, stove and laundry

Rent you lose after a fire or flood

No

Yes, while the unit cannot be lived in

Injury to a visitor or tenant on the property

Personal liability for your household

Premises liability as the owner of a rental

Your tenant's belongings

No

No, the tenant needs their own policy

A tenant who stops paying rent

No

No, this is not an insured loss


On top of that core, most landlords should look at sewer backup and overland water endorsements, which matter more in a basement unit than anywhere else in the house, along with coverage for bringing a damaged building up to current code during repairs.


What landlord insurance in Ontario does not cover

Landlord insurance does not pay for unpaid rent, your tenant's possessions, gradual wear and tear, or many losses that happen while a unit sits empty for longer than your policy allows.


Unpaid rent is not an insured loss

This is the most common misunderstanding we hear. Loss of rental income coverage pays when an insured event such as a fire makes the unit unfit to live in. It does not pay when a tenant simply stops paying.


That gap is real in Ontario. When the Ontario Ombudsman (external, open in new tab) investigated the Landlord and Tenant Board in 2023, the backlog had reached as high as 38,000 cases, and reporting at the time put typical waits at seven to eight months. Insurance does not fill that hole. Careful tenant screening and a properly completed lease are what protect you there.


Your tenant's furniture and electronics

Your policy covers what you own. Everything the tenant brings in is theirs to insure, which is exactly why tenant insurance exists. Our guide to tenant insurance in Ontario explains what it covers from the renter's side.


Long gaps between tenants

Most rental policies carry a vacancy condition. Once a unit sits empty past the number of days set out in your wording, coverage for losses such as vandalism, glass breakage and escaping water can be restricted or removed. If you expect a gap for renovations or a slow rental market, tell your broker before it starts, keep the heat on, and have someone check the unit regularly.


Empty rental apartment between tenants with keys and an inspection checklist, a vacancy period that affects landlord insurance in Ontario
The weeks between tenants are when vacancy conditions in a landlord policy start to matter.

Which rental situations need landlord coverage?

Any arrangement where someone pays you to live in a property you own needs to be disclosed, and the right policy depends on how the rental is set up.


Your situation

What usually applies

The question to ask your broker

Basement or in-law suite in the home you live in

Your home policy endorsed or rewritten for a rented unit

Does the policy require the suite to be permitted?

A whole house you moved out of

A rental dwelling policy

What are the vacancy terms between tenants?

A condo unit you rent out

A condo policy written for a rented unit

Does it cover the corporation's deductible if a leak starts in my unit?

A relative who pays you rent

Still a rental to most insurers

Do I need to disclose it if it is family?

A cottage or room rented by the week

Usually a home sharing endorsement or a different policy

Does my seasonal policy exclude paying guests?

Several rental properties

Often a commercial or scheduled policy

Can one liability limit cover every property?


Condo owners have an extra layer to think about, because damage that starts in a unit can trigger the condominium corporation's deductible. We cover that in detail in our guide to condo insurance in Ontario.


Can an Ontario landlord require tenant insurance?

Yes, a landlord can require liability insurance if both sides agree to it in the lease.


Section 11 of Ontario's standard lease (external, open in new tab) is where the landlord and tenant agree whether the tenant must carry liability insurance, and if the landlord asks for proof, the tenant has to provide it. Contents insurance is left to the tenant.


Requiring it protects you more than it might seem. If a tenant leaves a pot on the stove and the kitchen burns, the tenant's liability coverage can respond to the damage they caused rather than every dollar landing on your own policy and your claims history. Ask for proof at signing, and again at every renewal.


Legal suites, illegal suites and why it matters at claim time

Whether a unit meets building and fire code affects both your tenant's safety and how smoothly a claim is handled.


Ontario's additional residential unit rules (external, open in new tab) introduced through the More Homes Built Faster Act in 2022 allow up to three units on most residential lots as of right. That change removed the rezoning step. It did not remove the requirement that each unit meet the Ontario Building Code and Fire Code, with proper exits, fire separation, and working smoke and carbon monoxide alarms.


Units built without permits, or that do not meet code, are where claim disputes tend to start. Keep your permits and inspection records with your policy documents. If a suite was created by a previous owner and you are not sure of its status, your municipal building department can tell you what is on file.


Water stain on the ceiling of a basement apartment, a common claim under landlord insurance in Ontario
Water travelling down from an upstairs unit is one of the most common claims in a house with a basement suite.

Water is the claim we see most often in houses with a basement unit. When a supply line fails upstairs and the water comes through the suite ceiling, the landlord's policy responds to the building and the landlord's contents, and the tenant's own policy responds to their belongings. Our article on whether home insurance covers water damage explains the sudden versus gradual distinction that decides many of these files.


How much does landlord insurance cost in Ontario?

Landlord insurance usually costs more than an owner occupied policy on the same building, because rented properties produce more claims and the owner is not there to catch a small problem before it becomes a large one.


The actual premium depends on factors you can see coming:


  • How many units there are, and whether you live on site

  • The age of the building and the condition of the roof, wiring, plumbing and heating

  • Whether every unit is permitted and meets code

  • Your claims history as an owner

  • The liability limit you choose, where two million dollars is a sensible floor for a landlord

  • Endorsements such as sewer backup, which are worth having on any unit below grade


Placing the rental with the same broker who handles your own home insurance and auto often brings the overall cost down, and it removes the gaps that appear when two policies with two insurers each assume the other one is responsible.


Renting out property in York Region and around Lake Simcoe

A few local patterns come up again and again with landlords in this area.


Secondary suites in established neighbourhoods. Basement and in-law units are now common in Keswick, Sutton, Newmarket and Bradford, often in older homes where the wiring and plumbing were never designed for two households. Those are worth reviewing before you rent.


Cottages that earn a little rent. Around Lake Simcoe and Georgina, plenty of owners rent the cottage for a few summer weeks. Many seasonal property policies do not contemplate paying guests at all, so a single rental week can sit outside the coverage you thought you had.


Older rural houses. In East Gwillimbury, Mount Albert and Holland Landing, rented farmhouses often run on wells, septic systems and older heating. Insurers will ask about each one, and having the answers ready speeds everything up.


What to do before a tenant moves in

  • Tell your broker about the rental in writing, and get the change confirmed on your policy

  • Confirm the unit is permitted, and keep the permits and inspection records

  • Complete Section 11 of the standard lease to require tenant liability insurance, and collect proof

  • Photograph or video the unit at move in, room by room

  • Install and test smoke and carbon monoxide alarms in every unit

  • Ask what your loss of rental income limit is, and whether sewer backup is included

  • Read the vacancy condition so you know how many days you have between tenants


Renting out a suite, a condo or a second property? Tell us how the rental is set up and we will tell you whether your current policy covers it, what needs to change, and what it will cost to do it properly. Al Dorman Insurance Brokers has helped owners across Keswick, Georgina, Mount Albert, East Gwillimbury and York Region for more than fifty years. Learn more about our landlord insurance, request a quote, or get in touch.


Frequently asked questions

Is landlord insurance mandatory in Ontario?

No law requires it, but if you rent out a property your home policy may not respond to claims connected to the rental, and most mortgage lenders require the property to be properly insured for how it is actually used.


Does home insurance cover a basement apartment in Ontario?

Not automatically. Renting out a basement unit is a material change in risk that has to be disclosed. Once it is, the insurer can endorse or rewrite the policy to cover the rental properly.


What does landlord insurance cover?

The rented building, the appliances and furnishings you supply, rent lost while the unit is unlivable after an insured loss, and your liability as the owner of a rental property.


Does landlord insurance cover unpaid rent?

No. Loss of rental income coverage pays when an insured event such as a fire makes the unit unlivable. A tenant who stops paying is a matter for the lease and the Landlord and Tenant Board, not an insured loss.


Can a landlord require tenant insurance in Ontario?

Yes. Under Section 11 of Ontario's standard lease, the landlord and tenant can agree that the tenant must carry liability insurance, and the tenant must provide proof if asked. Contents insurance is the tenant's choice.


What happens if I do not tell my insurer I am renting?

A claim connected to the rental can be reduced or denied, a liability claim from the tenant may not be covered, and the policy can be cancelled for non-disclosure.


Do I need landlord insurance if I rent to a family member?

If they pay rent, most insurers treat it as a rental. Disclose it and let the insurer decide, rather than assuming family arrangements are exempt.


Does landlord insurance cover short-term rentals like Airbnb?

Usually not on its own. Short-term and weekly rentals generally need a home sharing endorsement or a different policy, so tell your broker exactly how you plan to rent.


Is landlord insurance more expensive than home insurance?

Usually somewhat, because rented properties produce more claims and the owner is not on site. The difference depends on the building, the number of units and the coverage you choose.


This article is general information about landlord insurance in Ontario and is not legal advice or advice on your own policy. Coverage, wordings and conditions vary by insurer. Al Dorman Insurance Brokers Ltd. has served York Region and the Lake Simcoe area for over fifty years, with offices in Keswick and Mount Albert. Speak with a licensed broker before renting out a property.


Comments


© 2022 Al Dorman Insurance Brokers Ltd. 

​

Monday - Friday                                                   

8:30 am - 4:30 pm

​

19150 Centre St, Suite 1

Mount Albert, Ontario, L0G 1M0

​

443 The Queensway South (Unit 26)

Keswick Ontario L4P 3J4

                                                                                                                                        

Local - (905) 473-2942                       

Toll Free - 1 (800) 387-9021

info@aldorman.com                                           

 

​

​

About Al Dorman Insurance Brokers Ltd.

 

Al Dorman Insurance is a family oriented brokerage, proudly owned and operated by Marlaine Miller and Curtis Armstrong. We have been serving East Gwillimbury, Georgina and surrounding communities for over 50 years! Many of our clients span multiple generations. We believe it is our unrivalled customer service our clients trust and respect that keeps our clients coming back, year after year.

 

​

​

Corporate Policy | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Accessibility | Sitemap | Copyright © 2025
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page